March 20, 2017 10:34 am

Norman Eng

This article was originally published on May 18, 2026 in Faculty Focus. To read in original format, go here.

Colleges and universities across the country are moving quickly to embrace artificial intelligence. According to an analysis of sixty-five R1 institutions, 63 percent of them actively encourage the use of generative AI, with many publishing detailed guidance for its classroom integration (McDonald et al., 2025). The implicit promise is that AI will sharpen student thinking, personalize learning, and better prepare graduates for a technology-saturated workforce.

But a growing body of research tells a more complicated story—one that faculty, instructional designers, and academic leaders should not ignore.

The Evidence Problem

The assumption driving AI adoption is that it improves learning. Yet the evidence, at best, is inconsistent—and in many cases, points in the opposite direction.

A Swiss study found a negative correlation between frequent AI tool use and critical thinking: the more students offloaded cognitive work to AI, the weaker their critical thinking became (Gerlich, 2025). Wharton researchers went further. Across multiple experiments, participants accepted AI-generated outputs with little or no scrutiny—a phenomenon they termed “cognitive surrender.” Unlike deliberate cognitive offloading, cognitive surrender involves a wholesale transfer of agency to the machine (Shaw & Nave, 2026). These findings are not isolated: a 2025 meta-analysis of eighteen generative AI studies confirmed that over-reliance on AI tools undermines higher-order thinking skills, including critical analysis and problem-solving (Qu et al., 2025).

The concern extends beyond AI specifically. Since K–12 schools began adopting laptops and tablets en masse in the early 2000s, IQ scores have fallen in ways that have no historical precedent. International assessments—PISA, TIMSS, and PIRLS—show declining performance correlated with heavier technology use (Horvath, 2026; Rogelberg, 2026).

Perhaps most striking is a 2025 randomized controlled trial—the gold standard of educational research—in which students who used ChatGPT as a study aid retained significantly less knowledge 45 days after instruction than students who studied without it (Barcaui, 2025). Short-term performance gains masked long-term learning deficits.

Why AI Shortcuts the Learning Process

  • Building and reinforcing a strong content knowledge base;
  • Opportunities for deep processing and productive struggle;
  • Independent and critical thinking; and
  • Meaningful human interaction.

The following four questions translate these conditions into a practical decision-making framework. Before integrating AI into any lecture, activity, or assignment, faculty should work through each one.

Four Questions for Deciding Whether to Use AI

Question 1: Will this AI tool help students use, recall, and demonstrate understanding of core disciplinary content?

Higher-order thinking is built on a foundation of domain knowledge. Students cannot analyze a lesson plan without understanding what learning objectives and assessments are. They cannot evaluate a scientific argument without knowing the relevant concepts. If an AI tool actively engages students with foundational content—through retrieval practice, targeted feedback, or elaborative questioning—it may be worth integrating. If it simply allows students to bypass that content, it is almost certainly counterproductive.

Question 2: Will this AI tool require students to apply their learning to a new context?

Transfer—applying knowledge to a novel situation—is one of the most reliable indicators of genuine understanding. When a student applies principles of lesson design to a new grade level or subject, they are moving information from temporary working memory into more stable long-term knowledge. If an AI tool scaffolds that transfer while preserving cognitive effort, it can be valuable. If it performs the transfer for the student, learning is short-circuited.

Question 3: Will this AI tool support—not replace—independent, evidence-based reasoning?

Critical thinking requires students to make judgments and defend them. A student writing a lesson plan must decide how to open the lesson, how to group students, and how to assess understanding—and then justify those decisions with pedagogical reasoning. Any AI integration that substitutes the AI’s judgment for the student’s own undermines this process. The test is simple: after completing the task, can the student articulate—in their own words—why they made the decisions they made?

Question 4: Will this AI integration preserve meaningful human interaction?

Peer feedback, collaborative problem-solving, and instructor-to-student (and student-to-student) dialogue do more than support academic learning—they develop the social and intellectual habits that define educated citizens. Human interaction sparks curiosity, broadens perspective, builds trust, and provides the kind of accountability that AI cannot replicate. Before integrating any AI tool, ask whether it complements or competes with these interactions. An AI-enhanced discussion board that replaces peer response with algorithmic feedback may sacrifice more than it gains.

Proceed with Caution

AI is not going away, and blanket resistance is neither realistic nor necessarily wise. There are genuine use cases where AI can support learning without undermining it. But the pace of adoption in higher education is far outrunning the pace of evidence. Faculty are often caught in the middle—pressured to integrate tools their institutions endorse and their students already use, without clear guidance on whether doing so will help or harm the people they are trying to educate.

It is also worth remembering that AI developers have profit motives that have nothing to do with improving student learning. The enthusiasm of technology companies should not be mistaken for evidence of pedagogical effectiveness.

The four questions above will not resolve every instructional dilemma, but they provide a principled starting point. If an AI tool cannot clearly support content knowledge, productive struggle, independent reasoning, and human interaction—the conditions we know produce learning—the default should be to leave it out. The burden of proof belongs to the technology, not to the faculty member who questions it.

References

Barcaui, A. (2025). ChatGPT as a cognitive crutch: Evidence from a randomized controlled trial on knowledge retention. Social Sciences & Humanities Open, 12, 1-13. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssaho.2025.102287

Gerlich, M. (2025). AI tools in society: Impacts on cognitive offloading and the future of critical thinking. Societies, 15(1), 6. https://doi.org/10.3390/soc15010006

Horvath, J. C. (in press). The digital delusion: How classroom technology harms our kids' learning—and how to help them thrive again. Penguin Random House.

McDonald, N., Johri, A., Ali, A., & Hingle Collier, A. (2025). Generative artificial intelligence in higher education: Evidence from an analysis of institutional policies and guidelines. Computers in Human Behavior: Artificial Humans, 3, 100121.

Qu, X., Sherwood, J., Liu, P., & Aleisa, N. (2025). Generative AI tools in higher education: A meta-analysis of cognitive impact. In Extended Abstracts of the CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI EA '25), Yokohama, Japan. ACM. https://doi.org/10.1145/3706599.3719841

Rogelberg, S. (2026, February 21). The U.S. spends $30 billion to ditch textbooks for laptops and tablets: The result is the first generation less cognitively capable than their parents. Fortune. https://fortune.com/2026/02/21/laptops-tablets-schools-gen-z-less-cognitively-capable-parents-first-time-cellphone-bans-standardized-test-scores/

Shaw, S. D., & Nave, G. (2026). Thinking fast, slow, and artificial: How AI is reshaping human reasoning and the rise of cognitive surrender. Working paper, The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania.http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.6097646

  • I’ve heard of using exit slips. In most of my classes, students have a worksheet they complete, related to that day’s lecture. The intent is for them to read the chapter before class, complete the worksheet at least partially (3-4 questions) and turn it end at the end of class. I know many answer some questions during the lecture. I have used the worksheet to aid in small group work relating to the info. It seems to work. I will have to try exit slips in my smaller classes. Thanks for a great post!

    • Thanks Terri. I do like the worksheet method you described b/c it acts as a guide for students throughout the lecture. With exit slips, I just cut a paper into 4 pieces and have them answer on those small sheets. Let me know how it goes!

  • Norman,
    I enjoy reading your blogs, though I lecture at a state college the content of this blog can be applied to that of high school leavers. I also lecture a Management course with adults and I can apply this concept to them as well. Thanks for these invaluable insights and keep them coming – I do appreciate them.

    • Thanks Katie! And you’re right that much of this can be applied to high school. In fact, that was the the premise of my book “Teaching College”–that college instructors should look to K-12 for instructional guidance. My professional goal with this blog and my work is to bring that insight to the higher ed level!

  • I wonder, do you use exit slips every class? It seems like a great way to assess but time consuming. I would like to know other alternatives to add on.

  • One of my favorite exit strategies is called 1-2-3
    At the end of the class, students have 1 minute to tell 2 students 3 things they learned about during the day’s class. Each student reciprocates. Takes maybe 3-4 min because there will probably be some duplication. Sometimes I switch it up to 1-2-2-1 or if it’s really challenging material 1-2-1-1-1. One minute, two students stays the same but either tell 2 new things and 1 you didn’t get, or 1 totally got it, 1 kinda, 1 are you sure that was English? Students email me their ‘this needs more for me to get it’ so I can do some revision or reteaching next time. Can also do a whole class thumbs up, thumbs wagging, thumbs down. Toss out three important things you want the class to carry away with them and -with their eyes closed- thumb vote their understanding. Only takes a second to determine do you need a lot of time to address issues, a shorter special seminar or some individual or small group tutoring. These work from grade 1 on up. At least they have for me. C

  • {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

     

    Usually the latter. That’s why I stop asking questions like, “Class, does that make sense?”

    It’s useless. Rarely do they respond with statements like, “Not really. Can you go over the theory of moral sentiments again?”

    A few students might say they “kinda” get it (which means they don’t). In a whole class setting, you’ll more likely get a blank look. Or the “let-me-review-my-notes-again” look.

    I was trying to describe the term executive function, the mental processes that enable us to get things done—manage time, pay attention, remember instruction, juggle tasks, and resist temptation. Executive function has been described as the air traffic controller of the brain. It’s an increasingly popular term in the field of early childhood development.

    But did my students KNOW what any of this means? Just because they think they get the material as it is presented is not the same as being able to recount it.

    (Psychologist Daniel Willingham explains the science behind this phenomenon in his post, “Why Students Think They Understand—When They Don’t.”)

    Take a bicycle, for instance. We’re all familiar with it. But do we actually know what it looks like? Go ahead, really think about how it looks like. In fact, draw it on a piece of paper right now.

    Seriously.

    Designer Gianluca Gimini and cognitive psychologist Rebecca Lawson asked participants to do the same thing. The result? The bikes people drew were mostly—and hilariously—impractical or not functional. If you want a good laugh, check some samples here and here.

    Regarding most things, we think we know. But we don’t.

    That’s why marketers run ads over and over. In a saturated market, products don’t strike a chord with viewers without repeated exposure. And people will buy familiarity—even if they know nothing else about a service.

    Hey, I know only one injury law firm in NYC by name—Cellino & Barnes—because I can’t get their advertising jingle out of my head.

    What does all this mean for you, the instructor?

    First, students absorb lectures less than you think. Second, they may confuse what they know with what they’re familiar with. I hear undergrads say, “Oh yeah, I know about Jean Piaget from another course!” But when we discuss him in class, it’s all new to them.

    So double check for understanding. Here are two ways.

    1. Ask pairs of students to explain the concept to each other

    One hint is to incorporate the prompt, “Yes and …” Here’s an example of an exchange:

    Student 1: “OK, executive function deals with organizing thoughts, impulse control, and flexible thinking, right?”

    Student 2: “Yes, and working memory, I think.”

    Student 1: “Yes, and it’s like an air traffic controller who has to figure out which planes to land first and which runways to use.”

    Student 2: “Yes, and executive function can actually be improved.”

    By articulating with peers, students demonstrate what they actually know, continue to build knowledge, and clarify misunderstandings. All in a low-stakes environment. There’s built in accountability. Your job is to walk around and listen in.

    2. Use exit slips during the middle or end of class

    Here, students briefly answer 1-3 prompts, such as:

    Describe executive function in your own words.

    Why is executive function so important to develop at a young age?

    What part of executive function could be more clearly explained?

    Notice the last question puts the burden on the teacher. It doesn’t ask, What part are you unsure of?, which may trigger self-esteem issues or feelings of defensiveness. For the student, it’s easier to admit to things that teachers could do better than to things he or she feels unsure of.

    Collect these slips, but don’t grade them. Instead, use them to: 1) check students’ understanding; 2) identify areas of instruction you can improve upon; and 3) determine how you want to help strugglers. Exit slips may take longer than turn-and-talks, but they are more informative.

    So in the end, I knew I had to find better ways to teach executive function. What did I do next term?

    I pushed them to think like teachers.

    Sitting in groups, students developed strategies to improve children’s working memory, mental flexibility, and self-control. Something they will definitely do as future teachers. I love that they came up with ideas like “counting to 10 before reacting” and “playing memory games.”

    All of the sudden, executive function became meaningful and concrete. I know, because I used exit slips!

    THINK They Know –> KNOW

    So every time I lesson plan, I ask myself: How can I help students move from the left side of the arrow to the right?

    >