December 13, 2020 5:13 pm

Norman Eng

This article was originally published on May 18, 2026 in Faculty Focus. To read in original format, go here.

Colleges and universities across the country are moving quickly to embrace artificial intelligence. According to an analysis of sixty-five R1 institutions, 63 percent of them actively encourage the use of generative AI, with many publishing detailed guidance for its classroom integration (McDonald et al., 2025). The implicit promise is that AI will sharpen student thinking, personalize learning, and better prepare graduates for a technology-saturated workforce.

But a growing body of research tells a more complicated story—one that faculty, instructional designers, and academic leaders should not ignore.

The Evidence Problem

The assumption driving AI adoption is that it improves learning. Yet the evidence, at best, is inconsistent—and in many cases, points in the opposite direction.

A Swiss study found a negative correlation between frequent AI tool use and critical thinking: the more students offloaded cognitive work to AI, the weaker their critical thinking became (Gerlich, 2025). Wharton researchers went further. Across multiple experiments, participants accepted AI-generated outputs with little or no scrutiny—a phenomenon they termed “cognitive surrender.” Unlike deliberate cognitive offloading, cognitive surrender involves a wholesale transfer of agency to the machine (Shaw & Nave, 2026). These findings are not isolated: a 2025 meta-analysis of eighteen generative AI studies confirmed that over-reliance on AI tools undermines higher-order thinking skills, including critical analysis and problem-solving (Qu et al., 2025).

The concern extends beyond AI specifically. Since K–12 schools began adopting laptops and tablets en masse in the early 2000s, IQ scores have fallen in ways that have no historical precedent. International assessments—PISA, TIMSS, and PIRLS—show declining performance correlated with heavier technology use (Horvath, 2026; Rogelberg, 2026).

Perhaps most striking is a 2025 randomized controlled trial—the gold standard of educational research—in which students who used ChatGPT as a study aid retained significantly less knowledge 45 days after instruction than students who studied without it (Barcaui, 2025). Short-term performance gains masked long-term learning deficits.

Why AI Shortcuts the Learning Process

  • Building and reinforcing a strong content knowledge base;
  • Opportunities for deep processing and productive struggle;
  • Independent and critical thinking; and
  • Meaningful human interaction.

The following four questions translate these conditions into a practical decision-making framework. Before integrating AI into any lecture, activity, or assignment, faculty should work through each one.

Four Questions for Deciding Whether to Use AI

Question 1: Will this AI tool help students use, recall, and demonstrate understanding of core disciplinary content?

Higher-order thinking is built on a foundation of domain knowledge. Students cannot analyze a lesson plan without understanding what learning objectives and assessments are. They cannot evaluate a scientific argument without knowing the relevant concepts. If an AI tool actively engages students with foundational content—through retrieval practice, targeted feedback, or elaborative questioning—it may be worth integrating. If it simply allows students to bypass that content, it is almost certainly counterproductive.

Question 2: Will this AI tool require students to apply their learning to a new context?

Transfer—applying knowledge to a novel situation—is one of the most reliable indicators of genuine understanding. When a student applies principles of lesson design to a new grade level or subject, they are moving information from temporary working memory into more stable long-term knowledge. If an AI tool scaffolds that transfer while preserving cognitive effort, it can be valuable. If it performs the transfer for the student, learning is short-circuited.

Question 3: Will this AI tool support—not replace—independent, evidence-based reasoning?

Critical thinking requires students to make judgments and defend them. A student writing a lesson plan must decide how to open the lesson, how to group students, and how to assess understanding—and then justify those decisions with pedagogical reasoning. Any AI integration that substitutes the AI’s judgment for the student’s own undermines this process. The test is simple: after completing the task, can the student articulate—in their own words—why they made the decisions they made?

Question 4: Will this AI integration preserve meaningful human interaction?

Peer feedback, collaborative problem-solving, and instructor-to-student (and student-to-student) dialogue do more than support academic learning—they develop the social and intellectual habits that define educated citizens. Human interaction sparks curiosity, broadens perspective, builds trust, and provides the kind of accountability that AI cannot replicate. Before integrating any AI tool, ask whether it complements or competes with these interactions. An AI-enhanced discussion board that replaces peer response with algorithmic feedback may sacrifice more than it gains.

Proceed with Caution

AI is not going away, and blanket resistance is neither realistic nor necessarily wise. There are genuine use cases where AI can support learning without undermining it. But the pace of adoption in higher education is far outrunning the pace of evidence. Faculty are often caught in the middle—pressured to integrate tools their institutions endorse and their students already use, without clear guidance on whether doing so will help or harm the people they are trying to educate.

It is also worth remembering that AI developers have profit motives that have nothing to do with improving student learning. The enthusiasm of technology companies should not be mistaken for evidence of pedagogical effectiveness.

The four questions above will not resolve every instructional dilemma, but they provide a principled starting point. If an AI tool cannot clearly support content knowledge, productive struggle, independent reasoning, and human interaction—the conditions we know produce learning—the default should be to leave it out. The burden of proof belongs to the technology, not to the faculty member who questions it.

References

Barcaui, A. (2025). ChatGPT as a cognitive crutch: Evidence from a randomized controlled trial on knowledge retention. Social Sciences & Humanities Open, 12, 1-13. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssaho.2025.102287

Gerlich, M. (2025). AI tools in society: Impacts on cognitive offloading and the future of critical thinking. Societies, 15(1), 6. https://doi.org/10.3390/soc15010006

Horvath, J. C. (in press). The digital delusion: How classroom technology harms our kids' learning—and how to help them thrive again. Penguin Random House.

McDonald, N., Johri, A., Ali, A., & Hingle Collier, A. (2025). Generative artificial intelligence in higher education: Evidence from an analysis of institutional policies and guidelines. Computers in Human Behavior: Artificial Humans, 3, 100121.

Qu, X., Sherwood, J., Liu, P., & Aleisa, N. (2025). Generative AI tools in higher education: A meta-analysis of cognitive impact. In Extended Abstracts of the CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI EA '25), Yokohama, Japan. ACM. https://doi.org/10.1145/3706599.3719841

Rogelberg, S. (2026, February 21). The U.S. spends $30 billion to ditch textbooks for laptops and tablets: The result is the first generation less cognitively capable than their parents. Fortune. https://fortune.com/2026/02/21/laptops-tablets-schools-gen-z-less-cognitively-capable-parents-first-time-cellphone-bans-standardized-test-scores/

Shaw, S. D., & Nave, G. (2026). Thinking fast, slow, and artificial: How AI is reshaping human reasoning and the rise of cognitive surrender. Working paper, The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania.http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.6097646

  • While I can’t do an optional final, I like this idea of providing some other way for students to “make-up” some assignment. I can easily see giving one more optional quiz, instead of final near the end of semester. I’ll experiment for next spring and let you know! Thanks.

  • Allowing an optional final puts some students at a disadvantage. Students who have an A already can put more time into studying for their other courses. So, some students are studying for 3-4 finals while others need to study for five finals. This latter group is at a disadvantage in the amount of time they have available for each final exam.

    • I hear you, Charles. One could plan the semester so that all the points are accounted for before the finals, i.e., all the quizzes + assignments = 900 points, which would be an A. And then those that missed a quiz or did poorly can do this as “extra credit.” So actually, it’s to help those that struggled most. That’s another way to think of it.

  • I like the idea of a comprehensive final exam and integrate it (when time permits) into most of my courses. That said, I typically have 4 exams during the course and each is worth 100pts – I try to lean more heavily on awarding points for discussions, practical assignment activities, and other team or group-like engagement. I’ve found that some of my students are really not good test takers, but are excellent communicators and engagers – while others are phenomenal test takers and essay writers, but no so much on the engagement side of things.
    Since my courses focus on Criminal Justice, Security, Drone Administration, etc., there is much more need for my students to develop and hone their interpersonal communication skills, than demonstrate their memorization skills.
    ~

    • I’m like you as well, Eugene, in placing less emphasis on finals and more on the work students do everyday—discussions, participating, reading, assignments, etc. Thanks for your thoughts!

  • As a Vocational Educator teaching high school seniors and adults to become outstanding Pharmacy Technicians, I find your concept interesting.

    There are indeed those students who learn well. Who are organized, demonstrate excellent skills and techniques, and who communicate very well. And mixed across the physical classroom are others who are not well organized, yet! Who are challenged in demonstrating the knowledge behind demonstrating great skills and techniques, and for whom either English is not their first language, or, if it is, they have not yet developed good communication skills to this point in the 9-month program.

    They must retain knowledge for our national certification exam. Learn not memorize. To me there’s a great difference. Anatomy, Physiology, and the Top 200 drugs with understanding of interactions and side effects is only “part” of knowledge they gain and must retain! Pharmacy calculations is another area requiring knowledge and skills, or medication and IV orders could go very far wrong.

    One thing found with many students over the years is commitment to quality and to excellence. I was blessed to be raised with these principles instilled from childhood. Working to instill this from the outside is challenging, at best. While giving students my all, I “must” maintain balance for the long haul. I tell them “I cannot want this for you more than you want it for yourself.” Lives are at stake at the end of their thought processes, words, and whatever they touch/do!

  • I’ve used the optional final essay for several semesters in my Composition classes. If students have reached the number of points they need (for a C) or want (for a B or an A), that essay is optional.
    It has taken some explaining and repetition to convince them they won’t lose points for not submitting the final essay.
    Once they get it, they’re relieved to be able to focus on final exams for other classes.
    I frame it as a privilege they’ve earned by working hard all semester.
    And, because it’s a reflective essay on how they view their progress as a writer during the semester, some submit it anyway. I love that!

  • I am excited about this option for our fundamentals of public speaking course. Students are always wanting extra credit for things not related to speaking. We are creating an option impromptu speech during finals for students who are seeking to increase their grade. This will allow students to engage in a skill that they can actually use and get feedback, rather than just seeking out points for points sake.

  • {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

    Provide an optional final. This is a collection of questions pulled from the weekly quizzes. It your course is scored out of 1000 points, this final could be worth, say, 100-150 points.

    This relieves you of negotiating every missed quiz or assignment. Students all want an exception made for them, so instead, tell them not to worry. They can make up those 20 points by taking the optional final.

    It also serves as a nice review of the course.

    Obviously, not every instructor can do this, but giving students choice is an idea that can be applied to other areas of teaching.

    I just like the idea that some students may decide to forgo the final if, for instance, they’ve already scored above 940 points during the semester, which would qualify as an A! Something to think about next term as we think ahead.

    Thanks to Lisa P., who teaches for the Film program @UCF Nicholson School of Communication and Media, for this tip!

    Might an optional final work for your course? Leave comments below.

    >